Family Court Practice, The
Order the 2021 edition due out in May
Court of Protection Practice 2021
'Court of Protection Practice goes from strength to strength, having...
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance Tenth Edition
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance is an authoritative specialist text...
Latest articles
One in four family lawyers contemplates leaving the profession, Resolution reveals
A quarter of family justice professionals are on the verge of quitting the profession as the toll of lockdown on their mental health becomes clear, the family law group Resolution revealed today,...
Family Law Awards adds a Wellbeing Award - enter now
This past year has been different for everyone, but family law professionals working on the front line of family justice have faced a more challenging, stressful and demanding time than most. To...
Pension sharing orders: Finch v Baker
The Court of Appeal judgment in Finch v Baker [2021] EWCA Civ 72 was released on 28 January 2021. The judgment provides some useful guidance on not being able to get what are essentially...
Eight things you need to know: Personal Injury damages in divorce cases
The “pre-acquired” or “non-matrimonial” argument is one which has taken up much commentary in family law circles over recent years.  However, the conundrum can be even...
Misogyny as a hate crime – what it means and why it’s needed
In recent weeks, the government announced that it will instruct all police forces across the UK to start recording crimes motivated by sex or gender on an experimental basis- effectively making...
View all articles

ADOPTION: Kurochkin v Ukraine (App No 42276/08)

Sep 29, 2018, 17:53 PM
Slug : adoption-kurochkin-v-ukraine-app-no-42276-08
Meta Title :
Meta Keywords :
Canonical URL :
Trending Article : No
Prioritise In Trending Articles : No
Date : May 25, 2010, 11:05 AM
Article ID : 90961

(European Court of Human Rights; 20 May 2010)

In the course of proceedings to end the adoptive father's marriage, a report was produced stating that the child's relationship with the adoptive father was positive, and that the adoptive father had authority over the child, whereas the child's relationship with the adoptive mother was negative. It recommended cancellation of the adoption, in view of the deterioration of the couple's marriage. The adoptive mother asked the court to cancel the adoption, on the grounds that the child had attacked her. Both the adoptive father and the child opposed this application (in relation to the father but not the mother); the child wanted to remain with the adoptive father and the adoptive father was willing to care for him. Shortly after the adoptive father remarried the adoption was annulled by the court, explicitly disregarding the child's wish to remain with the adoptive father, on the basis that the adoptive father had not addressed the child's aggression towards women, and that a sanction was needed. Although the court ordered that the child be taken into care (for placement in an institution) he remained with the former adoptive father, who was eventually appointed the child's ‘guardian'.

The ECHR, noting that lawful and genuine adoption established family relations, and attracted respect for family life, found a breach of Art 8. The appointment of the ‘adoptive father' as guardian did not remedy the interference with his Art 8 rights. Although the wide scope of the discretion to annul an adoption conferred on the court by Ukrainian law was reasonable and acceptable for Art 8 purposes, in this case there had been no issue with the applicant's ability to care for the child, the decision was based on a judgment that he lacked authority over the child and the impossibility of family life resuming with both adoptive parents. The domestic court did not seem to have considered the possibility of annulling the adoption in relation to the mother, but not in relation to the father. Punishment of the child's behaviour was not a relevant reason for splitting up an established family unit. The court seemed not to have considered the impact of the decision on the future well-being of the child, or considered alternative strategies to deal with the child's behaviour.

Categories :
  • Archive
  • Judgments
Tags :
Provider :
Product Bucket :
Recommend These Products
Related Articles
Load more comments
Comment by from