Her Honour Nasreen Pearce
Retired Circuit Judge:
The decision of the Supreme Court in Re T (Costs: Care Proceedings: Serious Allegation Not Proved) [2012] UKSC 36 [2013] 1 FLR (forthcoming) may lead local authorities to sigh a sigh of relief and regard themselves as immune from the liability for costs in care proceedings unless it is established that their conduct was reprehensible or unreasonable and a party who is denied public funding and thus the right to defend the allegations and a fair trial to feel a sense of injustice. Given that a local authority is under a statutory duty to investigate and safeguard children where it receives information that a child has been subjected to harm or is likely to be subjected to harm local authorities may work on the principle that it would be extremely rare for a party to establish that their action in instigating proceedings and their conduct within care proceedings was reprehensible or unreasonable. However the issue of a local authority's liability for costs is not so clear cut and there may well be circumstances where the criteria for an order for costs set out...
Read the full article here.