Smith v Bottomley and Coach House Properties Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 953 is an object lesson in penalties for parties for inadequate pleading; and (perhaps) reminds family lawyers of the strict application of rules as to implied trusts - especially in relation to detrimental reliance to establish a constructive trust.
Ms Smith (‘S') had had a lengthy but uncertain personal relationship with Mr Bottomley (‘B'): promises of marriage had failed to produce a ceremony; they had a child (now aged 18); and she worked for him in his militaria business. He also had a small property development company ((the second appellant) incorporated during the course of their relationship) which owned two properties and had conveyed to it a barn. S claimed a constructive half share in the barn (and to two other company properties) and that she was entitled to an additional £21 000 from another property sold by B which...
Read the full article here.