Spotlight
Family Law Awards 2020
Shortlist announced - time to place your vote!
Court of Protection Practice 2020
'Court of Protection Practice goes from strength to strength, having...
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance Tenth Edition
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance is an authoritative specialist text...
Spotlight
Latest articles
Resolution issues Brexit notes for family lawyers ahead of IP completion day
Family lawyer organisation, Resolution, has issued two joint notes to assist family lawyers in England and Wales ahead of the end of the Brexit transition/implementation period at 11 pm on 31 December...
Online filing is real-time on New Year's Eve: practice direction change to accommodate EU withdrawal arrangements
I have heard that there will be an amendment to the relevant practice directions to provide that online applications received on New Year’s Eve after 4:30 PM and before 11:00 PM will count as...
Northamptonshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust v AB
The issue in this case concerned AB’s capacity to make specific decisions about treatment relating to her anorexia nervosa. She was 28 years old and had suffered with anorexia since the age of...
EU laws continue until at least 2038 and beyond
The UK left the EU on 31 January 2020.  But in matters of law it fully leaves on 31 December 2020.  But EU laws will continue to apply, and be applied, in the English family courts from 1...
Remote hearings in family proceedings – how is justice perceived?
The motion for the recent Kingsley Napley debate:  “This House believes remote hearings are not remotely fair” was carried with a fairly balanced 56% in favour and 44% against....
View all articles
Authors

Villiers case goes to the Supreme Court

Jan 16, 2019, 08:18 AM
Slug :
Meta Title :
Meta Keywords :
Canonical URL :
Trending Article : Yes
Prioritise In Trending Articles : Yes
Date : Jan 16, 2019, 08:15 AM
Article ID :

The Villiers saga continues as Mr Villiers has now been granted the right to appeal to the Supreme Court following the decision of the English Court of Appeal, writes Lisa Reilly, a solicitor at Brodies LLP.


Why so important?

Mr Villiers’ case throws into sharp relief the problems which arise as a consequence of what is known as “forum shopping”. This stems from the difficulty with our legislation which allows parties to select the Court in the country which is more likely to provide them with a favourable settlement in certain circumstances. So for example, in the case of a Scottish husband and an English wife who live in Scotland for much of their married life as Mr and Mrs Villiers did, and following separation the wife returns south of the border, where should they divorce? Scotland is the obvious answer since the husband is still “habitually resident” here. That is precisely what Mr Villiers did since during their long marriage he and his wife had lived in Scotland –and most of their property remained here. But Mrs Villiers responded with an action for maintenance for herself in England .She could do this because she was by then habitually resident in England and Mr Villiers’ divorce action did not contain any application for maintenance. Accordingly Mrs Villiers was free to raise an action in England for maintenance and the Court made a generous maintenance award in her favour.

Shopping for the best deal
Despite the closeness of our countries geographically, Scotland and England adopt very different approaches to the issue of maintenance after divorce. In Scotland, divorce legislation encourages a clean break and courts rarely make awards of maintenance for more than three years unless the divorce itself causes serious financial hardship. Conversely in England lifetime maintenance is not unusual. The regulations governing maintenance, or the interpretation of them, allow for the possibility of Court actions running in parallel in two separate jurisdictions and couples have to endure the resultant uncertainty and expense. And so we await the outcome of the Supreme Court decision of Villiers with interest.

 

 
Categories :
  • Articles
  • News
Tags :
  • Divorce
  • scotland
Scottish flag
Authors
Provider :
Product Bucket : Marriage & Civil
Load more comments
Comment by from