Spotlight
Family Law Awards 2020
Shortlist announced - time to place your vote!
Court of Protection Practice 2020
'Court of Protection Practice goes from strength to strength, having...
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance Tenth Edition
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance is an authoritative specialist text...
Spotlight
Latest articles
Hundreds of thousands of companies worldwide fall victims to hackers every year. Is your firm one of them?
SPONSORED CONTENT Image source: Information is beautifulYou and other lawyers and legal assistants in your firm likely have accounts on the hacked websites listed in the image above. If a hacker...
New complaints handling guide offers advice to local authorities
The Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman is today issuing new guidance on effective complaint handling for local authorities.Based on previous documents, the new guide offers practical,...
EU laws continue until at least 2038 and beyond
The UK left the EU on 31 January 2020.  But in matters of law it fully leaves on 31 December 2020.  But EU laws will continue to apply, and be applied, in the English family courts from 1...
Family Law Awards winners announced in virtual awards ceremony
The winners of the Family Law Awards 2020 were announced at 4pm during a much-anticipated virtual awards ceremony. Over the past ten years, the Family Law Awards has recognised the leading players in...
Behaviour-based divorces still merit close consideration
Some recent cases illustrate the evidential and procedural issues involved in dealing with proofs on the merits of divorce, which are worth considering even though most cases may conclude on a...
View all articles
Authors

Barnes v Phillips [2015] EWCA Civ 1056

Sep 29, 2018, 21:10 PM
family law, divorce, imputation, barnes, phillips, Property, Unmarried couple, Beneficial ownership, Constructive trust
The man’s appeal from a determination that the woman held an 85% interest in the property they held as tenants in common was dismissed.
Slug : barnes-v-phillips-2015-ewca-civ-1056
Meta Title : Barnes v Phillips [2015] EWCA Civ 1056
Meta Keywords : family law, divorce, imputation, barnes, phillips, Property, Unmarried couple, Beneficial ownership, Constructive trust
Canonical URL :
Trending Article : No
Prioritise In Trending Articles : No
Date : Oct 27, 2015, 11:00 AM
Article ID : 114353
(Court of Appeal, Longmore, Lloyd Jones LJJ and Hayden J, 23 October 2015)

Property – Unmarried couple – Beneficial ownership – Constructive trust – Change to intention to hold property in equal shares – Finding that the woman held 85% of the beneficial interest – Whether the judge had erred

The man’s appeal from a determination that the woman held an 85% interest in the property they held as tenants in common was dismissed.

The man and woman lived together from 1989 and had two children together. The property was purchased in 1996 using a £25,000 pound deposit and the balance being funded by a mortgage. It was held by them as tenants in common in equal shares.

The man paid the mortgage and some of the bills while the woman paid for the remainder. She worked part-time after the children were born. Major works were carried out to the property to which both contributed. The man purchased a number of other properties as investments in his sole name. When he fell into financial problems the property was remortgaged but the man failed to pay off all of his debts which had been a requirement of the remortgage agreement.

When the relationship broke down the man only continued to make mortgage payments for 8 months and from 2008 onwards the woman had sole responsibility for mortgage repayments and she had sole financial responsibility for the children. She had also funded substantial maintenance works to the property. The property was now valued at approximately £497,500.

The woman initiated proceedings under s 14 of the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996. The judge found that the man had not given full and frank disclosure and where the evidence between the parties was in conflict he preferred that of the woman. He held that upon the purchase of the property the parties were joint tenants in law and equity as that was their intention. They both contributed equally to what was a marriage without ceremony. There was no direct evidence that the parties later intended that their respective shares in the property would change or how they would change. There was also no evidence from which their shares could be inferred and, therefore, the court would impute their intention on the basis of what was fair. The judge held that the parties held the property as tenants in common in shares of 85% held by the woman and 15% held by the man. The man appealed.

The appeal was dismissed. It was not the case that the judge had confused inferring with imputation. He clearly had in mind the importance of the distinction. His use of the word impute was deliberate and referred to the second stage of the process outlined in Jones v Kernott. The judgment was missing the first stage of the process of whether a common intention that the shares should change could be inferred but given his in-depth detailing of the Jones v Kernott judgment it was at least strongly arguable that the judge must have concluded that there was such a common intention.

It was open to this court to infer a common intention on the basis of the evidence. In the present case the weight of the evidence supported such an inference. The judge had not erred in his finding of the shares the property were to be held in and it had been open to him to take into account the man's supposed lack of child support payments.

Neutral citation: [2015] EWCA Civ 1056

Court of Appeal
Civil Division

Royal Courts of Justice
Strand
London
WC2A 2LL

Hearing Date: 23 October 2015


Before:

Lord Justice Longmore
Lord Justice Lloyd Jones
and
Mr Justice Hayden

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Barnes

v

Phillips

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 

Mr. Michael Horton (appearing by direct access) for the Appellant
Mr. Mark Simeon Jones (instructed by Dodd Lewis, Blackheath) for the Respondent 

The full judgment is available on the Bailii website:

Barnes v Phillips [2015] EWCA Civ 1056  

See also Gwyn Evans, 'Barnes v Phillips [2015] EWCA Civ 1056: Imputation! Imputation! Imputation!'
Categories :
Tags :
FLR
Provider :
Product Bucket :
Recommend These Products
Load more comments
Comment by from