Family

David Hodson on International Family Law: Relocation! Relocation! Relocation!

14 June 2010

David HodsonChild abduction is one of the worst events which can occur in the life of a child. It is a criminal offence. It is treated exceptionally seriously, with combined worldwide action. The consensual flip side is child relocation. A parent wishes to move abroad permanently with a child seeks the permission of the other parent or of the court. However whereas child abduction has at least two major international conventions supported by governments of over 70 countries with relatively harmonised law and approach, child relocation has no uniformity of approach, of law and of international convention. Until now.

A conference in Washington, USA, in March 2010 held under the auspices of the Hague Conference brought together over 50 lawyers and experts from many countries and produced an agreed resolution, the Washington Declaration (see  International Family Law 2 2010 at p 211). It identifies relevant factors for international relocation decisions. This is a major step forward. It is desperately needed to produce harmonisation of outcomes around the world, not least in England which has probably the world's most liberal and generous relocation law and which has attracted much criticism from English lobbying groups, family lawyers and some judges. Lord Justice Thorpe writing in June Family Law (at p 565) about the conference says that if England were to subscribe to the Declaration it would represent a significant departure from English relocation law principles. Yet he also accepts that it is not difficult to argue for a change in the law given the changes in parenting patterns over the past 40 years or so. Perhaps with a new President who has been previously critical of English relocation law, we can have a new direction very soon, giving greater weight to continuity and ongoing relationship with the so-called "left behind parent". A change is very overdue.

This makes even more vital the conference being held 30 June - 2 July 2010 in London by The Centre for Family Law and Practice, London Metropolitan University on International Child Abduction, Relocation and Forced Marriages. Over 150 of the world's leading family lawyers, academics, judges and policymakers are attending. It is to be hoped that good progress can be made towards harmonisation and mutual understanding of appropriate principles for permitting child relocation around the world.

David Hodson is a Consultant at The International Family Law Group. He acts in complex family law cases, often with an international element. 

He is an English specialist accredited solicitor, mediator, family arbitrator, Deputy District Judge at the Principal Registry of the Family Division, High Court, London and also an Australian qualified solicitor, barrister and mediator. He is a Fellow of the International Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers and author of A Practical Guide to International Family Law (Jordan Publishing, 2008). He is chair of the Family Law Review Group of the Centre for Social Justice. He can be contacted on dh@davidhodson.com.

The views expressed by contributing authors are not necessarily those of Family Law or Jordan Publishing and should not be considered as legal advice.

Downloads

Related Opinion

News
7 Jun

Opinion

David Hodson on International Family Law: Enhanced cooperation on EU divorces receives green light

2010-06-07 11:27:00 UTC

On Friday 4 June 2010, the Justice and Home Affairs (JHA) Council of the EU authorised the first "enhanced cooperation" in the history of the European...

More Info »
News
21 Jun

Opinion

David Hodson on International Family Law: Let the vuvuzelas sound: domestic abuse must be condemned

2010-06-21 10:40:00 UTC

As the eyes of the world focus on South Africa this month, attention rightly comes to its distinctive problems such as poverty in its townships and...

More Info »
News
25 Jun

Opinion

Sandra Davis' Week: Relocation? Relocation? Relocation?

2010-06-25 12:15:00 UTC

Relocation? Relocation? Relocation? Writing in these pages on 14 June David Hodson drew attention to the Washington Declaration on International Family...

More Info »
News
28 Jun

Opinion

David Hodson on International Family Law: Shackled by the need to file a marriage certificate

2010-06-28 10:25:00 UTC

In the Brussels II race to issue, English solicitors are often first to the chequered flag.  But just as we are about to cross the line by issuing...

More Info »
News
6 Jul

Opinion

David Hodson on International Family Law: English conference leads the way for international children

2010-07-06 12:05:00 UTC

Last week the Centre for Family Law and Practice, London Metropolitan University held perhaps the most important international family law conference...

More Info »
News
12 Jul

Opinion

David Hodson on International Family Law: The international pensions black hole

2010-07-12 10:40:00 UTC

The Supreme Court decision in Agbaje (2010) UKSC 13 created excellent fairness and justice opportunities for international families to seek some financial...

More Info »
News
21 Jul

Opinion

David Hodson on International Family Law: From Russia with a forged divorce

2010-07-21 11:35:00 UTC

The controversial comments made by LJ Thorpe last Tuesday in the Court of Appeal in Golubovich [2010] EWCA 180 raise many issues, on some of which there...

More Info »
News
2 Aug

Opinion

David Hodson on International Implications of Imerman: London: the divorce cheat's capital of the world?

2010-08-02 16:15:00 UTC

London has been described as the "divorce capital of the world", including by Lord Justice Thorpe in Charman [2007], our most senior international family...

More Info »
News
9 Aug

Opinion

David Hodson on International Family Law: Swiss clockmakers fail to tell the time: ECHR allows abduction after many delays

2010-08-09 11:10:00 UTC

There is much controversy across the child abduction world, between Europe and non-European countries, following a decision of the Grand Chamber of...

More Info »

Related Journal Articles

News
17 May

Journal Articles

References to the Court of Justice of the European Union in Family Proceedings

2010-05-17 17:30:00 UTC

THE RT HON LORD JUSTICE THORPE, Head of International Law for England and Wales, and ELEANOR SHARPSTON, Advocate General (CJEU) The opportunity for...

More Info »

Related Practice Guidance

News
26 Mar

Practice Guidance

Washington Declaration on International Family Relocation

2010-03-26 10:33:00 UTC

On 23-25 March 2010, more than 50 judges and other experts from Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Canada, France, Egypt, Germany, India, Mexico, New Zealand...

More Info »

Related Products

Pracguideifl_20small_index_cover

Family

Practical Guide to International Family Law, A

David Hodson

Provides a comprehensive coverage of the international elements of family law

£77.00

More Info »
Int_survey_fl_2010_cov_v1_index_cover

Family

International Survey of Family Law 2010 Edition, The

Professor Bill Atkin

Published on behalf of the International Society of Family Law

£75.00

More Info »
Ifl_index_cover

Family

International Family Law

Elizabeth Walsh

An unrivalled source of developments affecting international family law practice

£270.00

More Info »
Hague_20guide_20to_20good_20practice_index_cover

Family

Hague Conference Guide to Good Practice on Intercountry Adoption

-

This work deals with intercountry adoption matters under the 1993 Hague Convention

£42.00

More Info »