Family

Hayley Trim's Analysis:PRFD Conciliation Scheme

28 June 2011

Hayley Trim, Family Law PSLThe District Judge's Direction of 12 March 2004 sets out the procedure for conciliation appointments in private Children Act proceedings in the Principal Registry. The direction provided that these appointments were privileged and the judge could not make orders where the parties were not in agreement.

However FPR 2010 PD 12B (the Revised Private Law Programme) now takes precedence and where the conciliation scheme is inconsistent with that, it does not apply. Therefore the First Hearing Dispute Resolution Appointment (FHDRA) is not privileged - the judge and Cafcass officer can have further involvement in the case.

Also the judge can make an order where the parties do not entirely agree, for example about interim contact. However, despite PD12B indicating that the involvement of the child will be a matter to be considered at the FHDRA, the practice of children of age 9 and above attending court for the FHDRA to speak to a Cafcass officer is unchanged.  It is understood that further guidance on practice in the PRFD will be provided soon.

Give us your views by clicking here and joining our Linkedin discussion. What is your experience of involving the child at this stage of proceedings? Does it encourage parents to focus on the needs of the child and promote early settlement? Is it putting too much responsibility on young children?

Do you think the first hearing should be privileged? And should the judge have the power to make orders without the agreement of the parties to prevent one party holding the other to ransom?

Hayley Trim is a Family Law PSL at Jordan Publishing and was formerly a family solicitor practising in London.

She works on the Family Law online major works providing updating notes on cases and other relevant developments as they happen for The Family Court Practice, Children Law and Practice and Matrimonial Property and Finance online.

Related Opinion & Analysis

News
8 Jun

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Rules are made to be… amended

2011-06-08 13:50:00 UTC

Just when you thought you'd come to terms with the FPR 2010 (or perhaps got round to reading the really essential bits), the Family Procedure (Amendment...

More Info »
News
1 Jun

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Child maintenance: what the Duxbury?

2011-06-01 11:49:00 UTC

The case of N v F [2011] EWHC 586 (fam) is primarily about the treatment of non-matrimonial assets - here assets of over £2m brought into the...

More Info »
News
12 May

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis:The race to litigate or leg it

2011-05-12 11:35:00 UTC

Updated: 11:52, 13 May 2011 One of the recommendations of the (interim) Family Justice Review is that parents be given a leaflet when they register...

More Info »
News
6 Apr

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: D-Day: Navigating the new Rules. And the Practice Directions. And the Forms.

2011-04-06 01:00:00 UTC

It's here. 6 April 2011. The date has taken on a daunting significance since we first learned that the Family Procedure Rules 2010 were on the way...

More Info »
News
14 Mar

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Brain hurt

2011-03-14 16:00:00 UTC

My little grey cells have been working overtime this week. I have been to two extremely interesting Family Law conferences - Introduction to the Court...

More Info »
News
1 Mar

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Please just answer the question…

2011-03-01 07:49:00 UTC

In October 2009 a mother took her two month old daughter to Reunion Island, the mother's country of origin, to live there permanently. The father, who...

More Info »
News
11 Feb

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Short and sweet

2011-02-11 09:20:00 UTC

I was very pleased to see J v J [2009] EWHC 2654 (Fam) overturned by the Court of Appeal (Jones v Jones [2011] EWCA Civ 41). Shortly before I left practice...

More Info »
News
27 Jan

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: The view from the desk top

2011-01-27 13:45:00 UTC

This week I thought I would share with you some brief observations from my recent reading of three judgments. Re S (a child) (care order: fact finding...

More Info »
News
11 Jan

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Procedure and Prenups

2011-01-11 09:43:00 UTC

The Christmas decorations have been put back in the attic for another year, New Year resolutions made... and broken, and almost all the snow has gone...

More Info »
News
2 Dec

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Welfare first - intractable cases and the Family Justice Review

2010-12-02 15:50:00 UTC

When I was considering the case of L-W (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 1253, I did not have the benefit of Coleridge J's speech to the ALC on 26 November...

More Info »
News
17 Nov

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Re L-W

2010-11-17 15:00:00 UTC

Court of Appeal non-committal on enforcing contact: Re L-W (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 1253 When I read this judgment given by Munby LJ a big part of...

More Info »
News
28 Oct

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: A Local Authority v DL [2010] EWHC 2675

2010-10-28 14:45:00 UTC

Mind the Gap: The inherent jurisdiction and common sense to the rescue In the current climate of anxiety about the impact of financial cuts, I was...

More Info »
News
21 Oct

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Conscientious objections: the Dissent of Woman

2010-10-21 16:55:00 UTC

Fed up of Radmacher yet? This paragraph of Lady Hale's dissenting judgment re-ignited my interest.  "...the object of an ante-nuptial agreement...

More Info »
News
15 Oct

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Toothless?

2010-10-15 06:30:00 UTC

One of the most difficult things I found as a solicitor was asking clients for money. Legal fees have to be paid out of taxed income or savings while...

More Info »
News
30 Sep

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: K v B – the blurring of the lines.

2010-09-30 15:25:00 UTC

The mixing of money and children is a taboo for family lawyers which it is sometimes hard for the client to grasp. Of course when parties divorce, there...

More Info »
News
15 Sep

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: It’s only words…

2010-09-15 08:00:00 UTC

This week I found myself going round in circles on what seemed to be a very simple issue - can the court make a contact order without making a residence...

More Info »
News
3 Sep

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Conventional Impediments in Part III Claims

2010-09-03 13:45:00 UTC

The Supreme Court decision in Agbaje v Agbaje [2010] UKSC 13 highlighted the increased potential for bringing a claim for financial relief following...

More Info »
News
20 Aug

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: The battle against alienation

2010-08-20 14:13:00 UTC

What is the right approach to rebuilding the relationship between a parent and an alienated child? How far should the parent and the court go? How do...

More Info »
News
5 Aug

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis of Imerman

2010-08-05 11:35:00 UTC

What do we do now? It's not uncommon. We've all been there. A client comes in, perhaps at first meeting, before terms of business or any other advice...

More Info »
News
23 Jul

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Pre-pay and top-up - a wider Schedule 1 jurisdiction?

2010-07-23 15:05:00 UTC

Pre-pay and top-up - a wider Schedule 1 jurisdiction? Charles J recently gave judgment in CF v KM [2010] EWHC 1754 (fam). He held that the court had...

More Info »
News
9 Jul

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Misconceptions, mistrust and missed opportunities

2010-07-09 16:40:00 UTC

Misconceptions, mistrust and missed opportunities In Independent News & Media v A [2010] EWCA Civ 343 the Court of Appeal (consisting of the Lord...

More Info »
News
23 Jun

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Paying for Natural Parenthood

2010-06-23 17:35:00 UTC

Paying for Natural Parenthood On 16 June 2010 at the Children Law and Practice Conference, Madeleine Reardon spoke about the meaning and significance...

More Info »
News
11 Jun

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Beyond Radmacher

2010-06-11 12:15:00 UTC

Beyond Radmacher While we (still) wait for the judgment of the Supreme Court in Radmacher v Granatino Lord Justice Thorpe's thought-provoking Keynote...

More Info »
News
28 May

Opinion & Analysis

Hayley Trim's Analysis: The Cost of Justice

2010-05-28 16:15:00 UTC

In my first week as Family Law PSL at Jordans, "cuts" appears to be the media watchword of the minute. The news of a civil service recruitment freeze...

More Info »

Related Products

Icon_red_mouse

Family

Family Court Practice Online, The

The acknowledged authority on practice and procedure in family courts

More Info »
Children-law-binders_index_cover

Family

Hershman and McFarlane: Children Law and Practice

David Hershman, Andrew McFarlane

The definitive reference work on child law, used daily in courts everywhere

£540.00

More Info »
Icon_red_mouse

Family

Hershman and McFarlane: Children Law and Practice Online

The definitive reference work on child law, used daily in courts everywhere

More Info »
Mat_property___finance_image_index_cover

Family

Duckworth's Matrimonial Property and Finance

Peter Duckworth

Now includes fully updated pre-nuptial precedent to take into account Radmacher

£455.00

More Info »
Icon_red_mouse

Family

Duckworth's Matrimonial Property and Finance Online

The essential guide to ancillar y relief

More Info »