Family

Family Justice Review Published

03 November 2011

By Hugh Logue, Newswatch Editor

Family Justice ReviewThe Family Justice Review panel has today published its final report (download below) announcing a range of recommendations aimed at tackling delays and generally improving the family justice system.

Changes to public law children cases include a recommendation to introduce a new six month time limit in care cases so delays are significantly reduced. In addition the panel proposed that the family courts place less reliance on 'unnecessary' expert witnesses and reports and refocus on determining whether the child should go into care.

Law Society Chief Executive  Desmond Hudson said that the Government will have to find the resources to implement the recommendations.

"To effectively halve the time which cases take now will require additional resources - more court time and more judges' time.  It will also require more time from family solicitors, but that is under threat from cuts in legal aid fees and scope," Mr Hudson said.

In an effort to create a more consistent and simple court service, the review recommends more judges who are specialists in family law to hear cases from start to finish. As previously announced in the interim report, the proposals also include incorporating Cafcass into a new service where it would work jointly with the courts service, legal aid and other partner agencies within a single service.

Recommendations on private law children cases include a single online and phone help service to make it simpler for people to decide the most appropriate way forward and increase clarity of understanding. The panel also propose using Parenting Agreements and a new ‘child arrangements order' to bring together arrangements for children's care after separation, focusing on the child rather than ‘contact' and ‘residence'. As expected, the review recommends increased provision of mediation to prevent cases going to court unnecessarily.

David Norgrove, chair of the Family Justice Review, said: "Our package of recommendations to the Government and the judiciary will make the current family justice system more effective.  We need to eliminate the shocking delays in the system. 

"Every year 500,000 children and adults are involved in the family justice system. They turn to it at times of great stress and conflict. It must deliver the best possible outcome for all the children and families who use it, because its decisions directly affect the lives and futures of all those involved, and have repercussions for society as a whole."

The Government has welcomed the Review and has announced that from January 2012 it will publish court-by-court performance so everyone can see exactly where improvements need to be targeted. In addition it has announced that it will be increasing funding for mediation by two thirds to £25 million a year.

Fathers' rights groups have criticised the panel's decision not recommend that there should be a presumption in law of shared parenting.  

Ken Sanderson, CEO of Families Need Fathers, commented: "The core failing of the current family justice system is that the rights of children to maintain meaningful relationships with both parents, as set out in the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, are not adequately supported or enforced. By choosing not to address this issue, any other proposals to reform the system will be merely superficial adjustments to a fundamentally broken system."

However, Tanya Roberts, partner at Charles Russell LLP believes the panel's recommendations are appropriate.

"The Family Justice review makes interesting reading but its conclusions regarding grandparents and fathers are not surprising. They are sensible and measured and emphasise the most important aspect namely that decisions about children should be based on what is in their best interests and therefore what is appropriate in each individual case depending on its facts," Ms Roberts said.

To read more about the Family Justice Review, see the collected papers of the 2011 Dartington Hall conference which include a Memo to the Norgrove Committee from the Conference. 

Downloads

Related News

News
12 Jan

News

Update from the Family Justice Modernisation Programme

2012-01-12 18:55:00 UTC

Mr Justice Ryder has released his first update in his new capacity as Judge in Charge of the Modernisation of Family Justice. The role was created...

More Info »
News
22 Dec

News

Family Law News Review 2011

2011-12-22 14:32:00 UTC

By Hugh Logue, Newswatch Editor As 2011 draws to a close, Family Law Newswatch reviews the news stories you have been reading this year. Last year...

More Info »
News
31 Mar

News

Family Justice Review recommends new integrated Family Justice Service

2011-03-31 10:30:00 UTC

By Hugh Logue, Newswatch Editor The Family Justice Review panel has published their interim report today and recommended a range of reforms that...

More Info »
News
19 Oct

News

Resolution warns against simplistic family justice reforms

2010-10-19 00:05:00 UTC

Ahead of the Government's comprehensive spending review tomorrow, the family solicitors association Resolution has warned against "simplistic solutions...

More Info »
News
17 Feb

News

David Norgrove appointed as Chair of Family Justice Review Panel

2010-02-17 09:54:00 UTC

David Norgrove has been appointed as chair of the government's new review of the family justice system to examine how the current system can be reformed...

More Info »

Related Opinion

News
3 Nov

Opinion

Sandra Davis’ Week: Parallel Universe

2011-11-03 16:09:00 UTC

I can't imagine many policy makers will read more than three of the 225 pages of the Family Justice Review Committee's final report. Anyone in government...

More Info »
News
3 Nov

Opinion

Family Justice Review Analysis: Mark Paulson, The Law Society

2011-11-03 14:15:00 UTC

The Ministry of Justice today published the Family Justice Review's final report. The report's recommendations will need careful studying by everyone...

More Info »
News
2 Nov

Opinion

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Read all about it (or not)

2011-11-02 13:45:00 UTC

"Fathers denied a right to see children" - The Telegraph. "Fathers lose bid for equal custody rights after review of family law" - The Daily Mail. Serious...

More Info »
News
2 Dec

Opinion

Hayley Trim's Analysis: Welfare first - intractable cases and the Family Justice Review

2010-12-02 15:50:00 UTC

When I was considering the case of L-W (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 1253, I did not have the benefit of Coleridge J's speech to the ALC on 26 November...

More Info »

Related Products

Dear_david_a_memo_to_the_norgrove_committee_index_cover

Family

Dear David: A Memo to the Norgrove Committee from the Dartington Conference 2011

Rt Hon Lord Justice Thorpe, William Tyzack

The papers of the 2011 Interdisciplinary Conference at Dartington Hall

£35.00

More Info »
Children-law-binders_index_cover

Family

Hershman and McFarlane: Children Law and Practice

David Hershman, Andrew McFarlane

The definitive reference work on child law, used daily in courts everywhere

£525.00

More Info »
Icon_red_mouse

Family

Hershman and McFarlane: Children Law and Practice Online

The definitive reference work on child law, used daily in courts everywhere

More Info »
Icon_red_mouse

Family

Family Court Practice Online, The

The acknowledged authority on practice and procedure in family courts

More Info »
Flj_index_cover

Family

Family Law

Elizabeth Walsh

News, updates and case reports covering every area of family law

£286.00

More Info »
Flr_index_cover

Family

Family Law Reports

Rebecca Bailey-Harris, Caroline Bridge, Nigel Lowe

Law reports covering cases resulting from family and children law issues

£357.00

More Info »

NEW Family Law Online

- A Snapshot

View a one minute video of the NEW Family Law Online features.

 - Video Tutorials

Get up-to-speed with how to browse and search on the NEW service.

Click 'More Info' below to view the narrated video demonstrations.

More Info »

Laptop_and_play_image